I was trying to make ice cream that tasted like a vanilla Frosty, and while this isn't exactly that, it is exactly delicious! Plus, it's a no cook recipe! This makes 2-1 1/2 qt tubs of ice cream in my Cuisinart ice cream maker. Make sure the inserts are frozen for several days for best results. Check out buttermilk and Chick-0-Stick variations below, too!

Share: